Los Angeles Unified elementary students from overcrowded schools earned college test scores afterwards moving to newly built schools, but students in new high schools experienced no similar crash-land in scores, co-ordinate to a policy brief released today.

"The biggest proceeds was for those students who came from the most severely overcrowded elementary schools," said Bruce Fuller, professor of pedagogy and public policy at UC Berkeley.

The study by UC Berkeley researchers from Policy Analysis for California Pedagogy (PACE), an independent research center, looked at test scores from 2002 through 2008 for near 20,000 students attending 44 new elementary and high schools and the students who remained at the original schools. No center schools were included in the written report, New Schools, Overcrowding Relief and Achievement Gains in Los Angeles – Strong Returns from a $nineteen.5 Billion Investment. William Welsh, a Ph.D. educatee in the Section of Folklore, is the pb author.

Los Angeles schools faced serious overcrowding problems in the 1990s. In some other written report past Fuller, he noted that, for example, South Gate Eye School, congenital for 800 students, housed more than 4,200 in the late 1990s. Many of the elementary schools had three shifts of students sharing the same school – with ane shift not using the school at any moment in time, Fuller said. One uncomplicated school had about 3,200 students, he said, the largest in the nation. The schoolhouse year in these multi-track schools was almost 14 days shorter than the typical 180-day year, and teachers had to carry their supplies in rolling carts as they moved out of their room to accommodate a teacher from another shift.

To relieve the overcrowding, the district typically built every bit many as 3 new schools close to the original schoolhouse, Fuller said. The new schools had more windows, higher ceilings, wider halls, and served from 400 to 600 students.

"They tried to open the space – arrive more light, airy, and comfortable and get rid of that penitentiary feel," he said. Some schools had alcoves between classrooms that provided private office space for teachers, creating a more professional environment, he added.

The Robert F. Kennedy Community Schools cost $578 million before the K-12 complex opened last year. Click to enlarge.

The Robert F. Kennedy Community Schools cost $578 1000000 before the K-12 complex opened terminal yr. Click to enlarge.

The original loftier schools were similar to the onetime elementary schools, crowding in as many as 5,000 students. The new high schools, with updated labs and technology, business firm about 2,000 students. Course sizes in both simple and high schools remain about the same, notwithstanding.

The new schools also reduced the demand for busing students to other schools that were less crowded. At one point in the 1990s, about 25,000 students were beingness bused every day, co-ordinate to the report.

Mammoth public works project

The report's release coincides with the opening in LAUSD of 20 more new schools in add-on to the 130 built during the past decade through the sale of $19.5 billion in local and state bail funds. "With the exception of the federal interstate highway system, this is the largest public works project ever undertaken in the United States," the researchers said.

The high price tag has raised concerns about misuse of funds, peculiarly when the commune spent $578 million on i K–12 complex, Robert F. Kennedy Customs Schools, which opened in 2011. It was the third in a series of costly schools that included the $377 million Edward R. Roybal Learning Center built in 2008 and the $232 million Visual and Performing Arts High Schoolhouse in 2009.

Despite the positive findings for elementary school students, this report is unlikely to quell that controversy because at that place appeared to be no correlation between test score gains and building expense. Students attending cheaper new unproblematic schools had similar increases in their English and math California Standards Tests scores equally those attending higher-priced K–5 schools.

Enigma in high schools

In addition, the test scores of students attending new high schools actually dropped in math, though Fuller said the differences in the data amidst high schools were then great – including ii high schools that did prove gains – that it fabricated it hard to draw any conclusions.

Fuller called the poor showing by high school students "a lilliputian mysterious."

Nonetheless, he noted, "the history of school reform is that whenever y'all intervene with younger kids, y'all take a bigger impact. Younger kids are more than elastic and able to boost those growth curves." In addition, these new high schools had to create small learning communities within the high school, a new initiative supported by the Pecker & Melinda Gates Foundation. When such substantial reforms are initiated, Fuller speculated, they tin "create complexities and challenges that might not pay off" in increased exam scores initially.

The payoff for uncomplicated school students who moved from overcrowded atmospheric condition was significant. "On average, these 'switching pupils' outpaced the average LAUSD student by a gain equal to nearly 35 additional days of didactics a year," the report states. The gain was even greater – 65 additional instructional days – for students who came from severely overcrowded schools. Students who remained at their old, no-longer-crowded school also improved, though not as substantially.

Function of the "new school upshot" could be that new facilities attract younger and better-educated teachers, Fuller said. However, in uncomplicated schools "an boosted statistically significant effect of new facilities remains even when instructor quality controls are included."

Fuller said that he has talked to principals who said the new facility attracted teachers.

A take chances to recreate a school culture

Moving into a new building enabled Madison Elementary to start from scratch, with a new school culture. Click to enlarge.

Moving into a new building enabled Madison Simple to get-go from scratch, with a new schoolhouse culture. Click to enlarge.

But Gretchen Young, a principal at 1 of the elementary schools in South Gate that boasted the highest jump in test scores, said that wasn't her experience – at to the lowest degree not at first.

The Madison Elementary Schoolhouse building itself did non attract the teachers, who were forced to come to the new school when they preferred to stay at their old school where they had comfy relationships with their peers, students, and community.

At the start meeting when asked for volunteers to teach at the new facility, not a hand went up, Immature said. In the end, those teachers with the least seniority, including some with as many as 10 years, transferred to the new school.

"When the teachers arrived, we created our ain culture, mission, values," Young said. "We created the environment that we wanted for our school." The school emphasizes community interest and focuses resources on students who are behind. The new culture is what is responsible for the boost in test scores, she believes.

Her stance is mirrored by others who were interviewed past a UC Berkeley inquiry team. In a separate report by Pace and the Center for Cities & Schools released in 2009, Constructing Schools, Building Customs Appointment, 1 teacher told the researchers that if teachers feel part of opening a new school, they tend to "practise a amend job than when [they] come in and the school's already set the culture."

To get more than reports like this one, click here to sign up for EdSource'south no-toll daily email on latest developments in education.